National surveys of employers are projecting the largest health benefit cost increases in decades for 2027. Depending on the survey, projections range from roughly 8% to 11%, with the lower figures reflecting the cost-cutting steps employers plan to take. Those steps matter, because most of them change who pays. Once a renewal is final, every employer faces the same question: how much of the increase should the company absorb, and how much should employees share?

There is no universal right answer. This post explains what the national data shows, lays out the 3 main levers an employer can pull, and offers a simple framework for making the decision in a way that employees understand and accept.

What National Surveys Are Showing


These figures come from national surveys of employers, and some are preliminary, so they are best read as direction and not as precise forecasts.

  • A national survey of more than 1,800 employers projects that total health benefit cost per employee will rise 8.2% on average in 2027, which would be the highest increase since 2003, even after planned cost-reduction measures. Employers in that survey estimated the increase would be about 11% if they took no action.
  • In that same survey, 59% of employers plan cost-cutting changes for 2027, including plan design changes such as higher deductibles. The final results are due later in 2026.
  • A separate survey projects an increase of 11.1% before plan changes and 9.7% after them. In that survey, 85% of employers are planning or considering shifting costs to employees through premium contributions by 2028, compared with 44% today.
  • About 2 out of 3 larger employers, those with 500 or more employees, expect to raise the employee share of premiums. Many workers will therefore see their paycheck deductions rise faster than the overall average increase.

The survey data comes mostly from larger employers, so a group of 50 to 200 employees should not assume its own numbers will match. The direction, however, is clear. Employers across the market are deciding how to divide a larger bill.

The 3 Levers


Lever 1: Change the Premium Split

The employer can adjust the share of the premium it pays, either for all coverage or differently for employee-only coverage and dependent coverage. This is the most direct approach, and it leaves networks, benefits, and plan design untouched.

  • Advantage: Predictable for both sides, and employees keep the coverage they know.
  • Tradeoff: The cost reaches every employee in every paycheck, whether or not they use care, and the effect is largest for employees covering families and for those with lower pay.

Lever 2: Change the Plan Design

The employer can adjust deductibles, copays, or out-of-pocket maximums, or add a lower-cost plan option alongside the current plan. Some employers are also adding plans that lower member costs when people use higher-performing providers. In a national survey, 12% of larger employers planned to offer a variable copay plan of this type in 2027.

  • Advantage: It reduces premium, and it can preserve the company contribution that employees see.
  • Tradeoff: It moves cost from the paycheck to the point of care, which means the employees who use the plan most feel it most. A single higher deductible can also be difficult for employees who are not prepared for it.

Lever 3: Absorb More at the Company Level

The employer can choose to pay the larger share of the increase and hold employee contributions steady or close to it.

  • Advantage: It protects employees, and it can support retention and recruiting in a competitive labor market.
  • Tradeoff: It has a real budget impact, and it is difficult to repeat year after year when costs keep rising. It tends to work best as a deliberate choice with a plan for the following year and not as a default.

What Employees Tend to Prefer


Employee preferences are worth understanding before a decision is made. In a national employee survey, 58% of respondents said they would rather pay higher out-of-pocket costs than accept a plan with more restrictions, such as a narrower network. In the employer survey data, 80% of employers said they prefer long-term, multiyear solutions over immediate savings, and many are cautious about changes that could be too disruptive.

This is a single survey, and preferences vary from group to group. A workforce with many families may feel differently from one that is mostly single and young. The most reliable approach is to ask your own employees, or to look at how they actually use the plan.

A Framework for Deciding

  • Reduce the increase first. Before deciding who pays, make sure the renewal itself has been tested against the market, including other carriers, plan designs, and funding structures. Every point of increase that is removed is a point nobody has to share.
  • Decide what you are protecting. Common goals include lower-paid employees, families, retention, or a firm budget ceiling. Different goals point toward different levers.
  • Model real employees, not averages. Look at the impact by coverage tier, including employee-only, employee plus spouse, and family, and at a few typical employees at different pay levels and usage.
  • Combine levers modestly. A small change to the premium split, a small plan design adjustment, and a measured company contribution are often easier for employees to accept than a single large move.
  • Communicate early and plainly. Explain what changed and why before open enrollment begins, and show employees what the company is paying as well as what they are paying.

Questions to Ask Your Advisor


These are the questions worth putting to your advisor as you decide how to handle the 2027 increase.

  • Has the renewal been marketed, and how much of the increase could be reduced before we decide how to share it?
  • What would each lever cost the company and each employee, by coverage tier?
  • Which plan design changes would reduce premium without creating a hardship for employees who have claims?
  • How do our contributions compare with similar employers in our market?
  • What is the plan for 2028 if costs keep rising at this pace?
  • How should we communicate the change to employees, and when?

At Cypress Benefit Solutions, we believe the way an increase is shared matters as much as the size of the increase. Whether the right answer for your group is a different premium split, a plan design change, or a larger company contribution, it should come from your own data and your own goals. If you would like help modeling the options before your decisions are final, we would welcome the conversation.

Ready to transform your employee benefits and personal insurance experience?

Discover the difference a dedicated, expert team can make. Whether you’re looking for comprehensive group insurance, retirement plans, or personal coverage, Cypress Benefit Solutions is here to provide tailored solutions that meet your unique needs. Don’t wait—secure your current and future needs today.

Contact us now to schedule your free consultation and take the first step toward a brighter, more secure tomorrow.

Smiling professional woman at a desk with a laptop
Cypress Benefit Solutions logo

8936 Northpointe Executive Park Dr Ste 240
Huntersville, NC 28078